Coronavirus: TraceTogether data used in murder case, Singapore minister says as he defends police access to contact-tracing programme


Senior government ministers in Singapore on Tuesday defended the use of data from the country’s Covid-19 contact-tracing programme in criminal investigations, saying it would be used only in cases involving “serious offences”.
Police had used the information from the TraceTogether programme in just one investigation so far – a murder case, the ministers said.
The comments in parliament on Tuesday followed the disclosure by Desmond Tan, the Minister of State for Home Affairs, on Monday that police were allowed to access the data under the Criminal Procedure code.
Get the latest insights and analysis from our Global Impact newsletter on the big stories originating in China.
The admission prompted controversy because the Singapore authorities, in an effort to boost public participation in the programme, had previously stressed the data would be used only for contact-tracing purposes.
Both Law and Home Affairs Minister K Shanmugam and Minister-in-Charge of the Smart Nation Initiative Vivian Balakrishnan defended use of the data by police in cases of serious crimes.
“Let’s say there is a murder … and information is available on (TraceTogether), if police chose not to seek that information, you can imagine how the victim’s family and indeed the rest of Singapore might react to that situation,” Shanmugam said.
Balakrishnan said that “so far, I think there has been only one (use of the data by police), which involved a murder case”, though he added he was “not privy to operational details”.
Balakrishnan, who is also the foreign affairs minister, added that the data was “not something to be accessed lightly or trivially – only for serious crimes, and to be used very judiciously and with utmost discretion”.
Previously the government had said the data would be anonymised and encrypted, and only unlocked if a person were to catch the disease to enable the tracing of their close contacts. Balakrishnan himself said at a press conference in June last year saying that the data would be used “purely for contact tracing. Period.”
However, in parliament on Tuesday, Balakrishnan said when he had made his earlier comments, “the (Criminal Procedure Code) was not on my mind”. He said when he realised the code would apply to data from TraceTogether he had “sleepless nights” wondering if he should persuade his colleagues to change the law.
Following reflection, he had “come to the conclusion that right now we are doing well … And so long as this government is able to maintain our reputation for openness, transparency, reliability, I think we are still on the right track”.
On Monday evening, following Tan’s disclosure about police access to the data, the TraceTogether website was updated with a paragraph stating the data could be used to guard the safety and security of citizens. “We want to be transparent with you,” read the website.
The ministers’ comments came in response to questions from lawmakers who wanted to know what impact the controversy would have on the public’s adoption of TraceTogether, currently thought to have been adopted by 78 per cent of the population.
Previously, the government has used further relaxation of social distancing rules – the third and final phase of reopening – to coax foe higher adoption of TraceTogether.
Lawmakers also asked whether data would be deleted if it was not useful to the police and why the disclosure had not been made earlier.
Users of social media had reacted with anger to Tan’s comments, with many sharing a cartoon by comic artist Sonny Liew that depicted a minister with a long nose – his speech bubble promising the data would only be used for Covid-19 purposes.
Critics said the about-turn had marred Singapore’s otherwise widely praised Covid-19 containment efforts. Experts had previously attributed the high adoption rate of TraceTogether to high levels of trust in the Singapore government. Such trust comes in stark contrast to the situation faced by governments across the world where many populations have resisted tracking apps on privacy grounds.
Japan launched its contact-tracing app in June and it was downloaded 4.4 million times in the first week. But uptake slowed dramatically, and as of July there were still only 7.69 million users out of an adult population of 105 million. Hong Kong, meanwhile, rolled out its “Leave Home Safe” mobile app in November, but the app met a mixed response due to difficulties in usage and privacy fears.
Deputy Director of Human Rights Watch’s Asia Division Phil Robertson said there had been a “betrayal of (Singapore’s) solemn promises to limit the use of TraceTogether information to public health matters” and said the government was “covertly exploiting the pandemic” to deepen surveillance and control.
Natalie Pang, senior lecturer at the communications and new media department of the National University of Singapore, said most Singaporeans would be “okay with data being used for criminal investigations if they understand it as protection and maintaining public safety and order – but the purpose of use is one thing, being informed about the purpose is another”.
But Pang said there would be major implications given the way this was communicated. “The public may now wonder about future uses of data that has already been collected, how they will be informed and if there are choices in future use.”
She added that if communications were “not managed well, this could impact public trust in the governance of data collected via TraceTogether and support of future data collection programmes”.
Teo Yi-Ling, a senior fellow at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies’ Centre of Excellence for National Security, said citizens felt they had been “baited and switched”.
“There is the perception of inconsistency of information from the government,” she said. “This apparent incoherence on the part of the government is objectively damaging to any attempt to win the Singapore public’s trust in this respect.”
Balakrishnan on Tuesday said Singapore’s police force was effective and enjoyed trust and cooperation that set a “right” balance. In contrast, he said authorities in the United States could not legally access data on a dead terrorist’s locked phone and ended up paying millions to hack the phone.
The minister doubted that the public’s uptake of the app would be affected and said most Singaporeans were not involved in assisting in criminal investigations, so “in that sense, they’re not affected”.
He also emphasised that the government had decided to be “upfront”.
“We must be forthright, honest, open, transparent, and do the best that we can. And it is in that spirit, therefore, that we have these open discussions,” Balakrishnan said.
The open discussions, he said, were why “the participation rate in contact tracing – using the latest tools that we have available – will remain high and why I hope we will continue to be one of the bright spots in the world”.
Teo agreed. She said people needed to use TraceTogether to get on with their lives, and this was a learning opportunity for the government and for citizens.
“It is also the basis of having a robust public discussion on what are arguably two fundamental issues here: the lack of understanding around the legal protection of privacy in Singapore, and what a government needs to work on in winning and maintaining the public’s trust in dealing with this issue of privacy,” she said.
This article originally appeared on the South China Morning Post (www.scmp.com), the leading news media reporting on China and Asia.
Copyright (c) 2021. South China Morning Post Publishers Ltd. All rights reserved.
Diagnostic Tool

UPS driver fired after racist rant outside Latino man’s home caught on video


UPS driver fired after racist rant outside Latino man’s
A UPS delivery driver was fired after he was caught on a doorbell camera going on a racist rant in front of a Latino man’s home. In the video, which was recorded Dec. 17, a man wearing a UPS


Security cam caught UPS driver’s racist rant as he …
Security cam caught UPS driver’s racist rant as he declined to deliver Latino man’s Christmas package When a UPS driver walked onto the front porch of a Milwaukee home last month, the man eyed …


UPS worker seen on racist rant video while delivering to a …
UPS worker seen on racist rant video while delivering to a Latino household has been fired “This is about the things people do when they think no one is watching them,” said the mother of a young …


UPS worker seen on racist rant video while delivering to a …
A UPS driver who went on a racist rant while delivering a package to a Latino household in Milwaukee several days before Christmas Day has been terminated, a company spokesperson told NBC News on Tuesday. … Video caught by the home’s doorbell camera on the evening of Dec. 17 shows a white man wearing a … Aviles and Forward Latino are urging …


UPS worker seen on racist rant video while delivering to a …
A UPS driver who went on a racist rant while delivering a package to a Latino household in Milwaukee several days before Christmas Day has been terminated, a company spokesperson told NBC News on Tuesday.Video caught by the home’s doorbell camera on the evening of Dec. 17 shows a white man wearing a UPS uniform, standing on a porch while holding a package and writing what appears to be a …


UPS worker seen on racist rant video while delivering to a …
A UPS driver who went on a racist rant while delivering a package to a Latino household in Milwaukee several days before Christmas Day has been terminated, a company spokesperson told NBC News on Tuesday. Video caught by the home’s doorbell camera on the evening of Dec. 17 shows a…


UPS worker seen on racist rant video while delivering to a …
A UPS driver who went on a racist rant while delivering a package to a Latino household in Milwaukee several days before Christmas Day has been terminated, a company spokesperson told NBC News on …


UPS worker seen on racist rant footage while delivering to …
A UPS driver who went on a racist rant while delivering a package to a Latino household in Milwaukee several days before Christmas Day has been terminated, a company spokesperson told NBC News on Tuesday. … Footage caught by the home’s video doorbell camera on the evening of Dec. 17 shows a white man wearing a UPS uniform, standing on a porch …


Security cam caught UPS driver’s racist rant as he …
Video of the Dec. 17 incident shows the unidentified UPS driver approaching Aviles’s front door at around 7 p.m. After his rant, the driver pasted the failed delivery note on the door, shaking his head in apparent disapproval.


UPS worker seen on racist rant footage while delivering to …
link to original article UPS worker seen on racist rant footage while delivering to a Latino household has been terminated NBC News UPS fires driver after ‘racist remarks’ caught on doorbell camera WTMJ-TV UPS driver fired after he was caught using demeaning language while delivering package to south side Milwaukee home Milwaukee Journal Sentinel UPS driver fired after […]

Tagged : / /

Top Republican Warns Of Democratic ‘death Spiral’ If Biden Win Overturned


‘Stopping Biden win could prompt death of US democracy …
‘Stopping Biden win could prompt death of US democracy’: Top Republican. Top Republican in Congress shoots down Trump loyalists trying to overturn election result


McConnell: Democracy ‘would enter a death spiral’ if
As Congress met Wednesday to formalize President-elect Joe Biden’s election win, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) warned that overturning the results would permanently harm American democracy.McConnell delivered a speech on Wednesday afternoon as lawmakers met to count electoral votes and some Republicans objected to the certification. The Republican leader spoke out against …


McConnell rebukes effort to overturn Electoral College …
If this election were overturned by mere allegations from the losing side our democracy would enter a death spiral. We’d never see the whole nation accept the election again,” McConnell said.


These Are the Members of Congress Who Want to Overturn …
The challenge would have to pass the House of Representatives, which Democrats control, and the Senate, where even top Republicans like Majority Leader Mitch McConnell have privately urged lawmakers against disputing Biden’s win. “The president and his allies are playing with fire,” Nebraska Sen. Ben Sasse wrote on Facebook last month


WATCH LIVE: Lockdown at Capitol Trump supporters storm …
The Senate’s top Republican has told his colleagues that Congress should not override the voters’ verdict in electing Democrat Joe Biden president, saying, “If we overrule them we will …


See GOP senator’s reaction to Trump’s ‘death wish’ tweet
See GOP senator’s reaction to Trump’s ‘death wish’ tweet. December 29, 2020, 3:55 PM … has descended into the world of conspiracy theories as he pursues long-shot attempts to overturn President-elect Joe Biden’s win.White appears to be the basis for at least some of the bizarre claims Wood has made on Twitter about Chief Justice John …


GOP super PAC releases new ads targeting Biden on China …
GOP super PAC releases new ads targeting Biden on China. WASHINGTON — Allies of President Trump are finally responding to Democratic super PAC ads criticizing the president’s coronavirus response — with a new set of ads attacking former Vice President Joe Biden.. As part of its multi-million ad buy in Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, the pro-Trump super PAC, America First Action …


Live coverage of DC protests: Capitol locked down as …
McConnell rebukes Trump, warns of ‘damage’ to country if GOP votes to ‘overturn’ election Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) called for senators to reject the effort to “overturn a …


Here’s how Trump will steal the 2020 election …
The Democrats were so happy because despite the Republican Party’s impediments and interference, the Democratic-backed judge won. The Democrats thought that would be the end of it and that the …


What’s in the Covid relief bill? Democrats and Republicans
The new bill, set to be voted on late Monday, won’t include any funding for states, a top Democratic priority. It will also exclude the Republican priority of liability protection from Covid-19-related lawsuits for businesses. Both parties touted wins in the legislation, part of a larger government funding bill, that play to their constituents.
autel code reader

Tagged : / /

Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei der OPEC!)


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei
Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei der OPEC!) Lufthansa-Aktie: Das sind meine Erwartungen an 2021! Gazprom & Nord Stream 2: Spannende Aussagen zur EU-Pipeline! Tesla geht nach Indien: Was zu erwarten ist; In diesem Pandemie-Film wären Zoom und Beyond Meat Superhelden; Weitere Alle Artikel mit Aktienanalysen →


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei
Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei der OPEC!) 05.01.21, 09:06 Fool.de Die Öl -Aktien Royal Dutch Shell, BP und weitere haben es immerhin auf ein versöhnliches Jahresende …


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei
Die OPEC tagt derzeit wieder. Hier ist, was Investoren von Royal Dutch Shell, BP und Co. jezt wissen sollten! The post Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei der OPEC!) appeared first on The Motley Fool Deutschland.


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei
05.01.2021 – Die Öl-Aktien Royal Dutch Shell (WKN: A0ER6S), BP (WKN: 850517) und weitere haben es immerhin auf ein versöhnliches Jahresende geschafft. Die Anteilsscheine der Ölkonzerne konnten …


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei
Die OPEC tagt derzeit wieder. Hier ist, was Investoren von Royal Dutch Shell, BP und Co. jezt wissen sollten! The post Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei der OPEC!) appeared first on The Motley Fool Deutschland. [The Motley Fool Deutschland]


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: OPEC+-Deal! Und jetzt? | The …
Was das für Shell, BP und Co. bedeutet. Bleibt nun natürlich noch die spannende Frage, was das für die Ölförderer wie Royal Dutch Shell, BP und die vielen, vielen anderen Namen bedeutet. Grundsätzlich handelt es sich hierbei um ein positives Zeichen. Und das in zweierlei Hinsicht.


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Die OPEC dämpft die Euphorie!
Royal Dutch Shell, BP und andere Öl- und Erdgaskonzerne leiden unter einer Prognose der OPEC. Das gilt es jetzt zu wisssen. The post Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Die OPEC dämpft die Euphorie …


Research-Fazits zu Bayer, MorphoSys, Shell
Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: Es wird wieder spannend (bei der OPEC!) Die Öl-Aktien Royal Dutch Shell (WKN: A0ER6S), BP (WKN: 850517) und weitere haben es immerhin auf ein versöhnliches …


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: OPEC+-Deal! Und jetzt? – onvista
Die Aktien von Royal Dutch Shell, BP und Co. haben in letzter Zeit von den gestiegenen Ölpreisniveaus massiv profitiert. Das hat gezeigt, dass die von der OPEC+ beschlossenen Förderkürzungen …


Börse Express – Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: OPEC+-Deal …
Was das für Shell, BP und Co. bedeutet. Bleibt nun natürlich noch die spannende Frage, was das für die Ölförderer wie Royal Dutch Shell, BP und die vielen, vielen anderen Namen bedeutet …


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: OPEC+-Deal! Und jetzt? Von …
Was das für Shell, BP und Co. bedeutet Bleibt nun natürlich noch die spannende Frage, was das für die Ölförderer wie Royal Dutch Shell, BP und die vielen, vielen anderen Namen bedeutet …


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co unter Wasser: Kollaps am …
Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co massiv unter Druck: Ölpreise mit stärksten Preisabschlagen seit Jahren Entsprechend setzte der Ölpreis seine Talfahrt der vergangenen Wochen am Freitag fort.


Dividenden heftig gekürzt: BP und Shell schaufeln sich ihr …
Bei Öl-Multis wie BP und Shell ist die Lage desolat, wie Milliarden-Verluste zeigen. Die Corona-Krise hat sie schwer getroffen. Auch die Dividenden sind da nicht mehr sicher – was vielen Anlegern …


Royal Dutch Shell und BP: Morgan Stanley sieht schwarz …
Royal Dutch Shell (WKN: A0D94M) Es dürfte spannend werden, ob und wann sich die gebeutelten Aktien von Shell und BP aus ihren hartnäckigen Abwärtstrends befreien können. Bis es soweit ist, sollten…


Royal Dutch Shell, BP & Co.: OPEC+-Deal! Und jetzt …
Das Online-Portal des Wirtschaftsmagazins Capital mit Reportagen, Analysen, Kommentaren aus der Welt der Wirtschaft und der persönlichen Finanzen.


SHELL (ROYAL DUTCH SHELL) (A) AKTIE | Aktienkurs | Kurs …
SHELL (ROYAL DUTCH SHELL) (A) AKTIE und aktueller Aktienkurs. Nachrichten zur Aktie Shell (Royal Dutch Shell) (A) | A0D94M | RYDAF | GB00B03MLX29


Royal Dutch Shell – Wikipedia
Die Royal Dutch Shell (RDS) … Das niederländische Unternehmen wurde zur Royal Dutch Petroleum Company umbenannt. Im Juli 2005 wurden beide Unternehmen zur Royal Dutch Shell plc vereinigt, einer Aktiengesellschaft nach englischem Recht, die an den Börsen in London, Amsterdam und New York notiert ist. Der Unternehmenssitz ist in Den Haag. Zu den Großaktionären des Unternehmens gehört …


Royal Dutch Shell Aktie: Keines der Geschäftsfelder konnte …
2019 sank der Umsatz um 11,2% auf 344,9 Mrd $. Der Gewinn lag mit 15,8 Mrd $ 32,2% niedriger. Das in der Ölbranche entscheidende operative Ergebnis vor


Royal Dutch Shell-Aktie: Kursexplosion voraus? – Finanztrends
Denn: Royal Dutch Shell befindet sich übergeordnet in einem charttechnischen Aufwärtstrend. Die Notierungen sind indes seit einigen Monaten an der überaus mächtigen Hürde von 30 Euro gescheitert. Nach einem Rücksetzer im Spätsommer bis auf 27,50 Euro konnten die Kurse wieder aufsatteln. Damit nähert sich der nächste Versuch, jetzt auf über 30 Euro zu klettern. Es wird spannend.


OPEC + – Forum – ARIVA.DE
Wie heisst es so schön: Es bedarf an Geduld und die nötige Feinjustierung (gerade in Krisen wie dieser!) um sich laaaangfristig (und nicht bei knappen, kleinen Gewinnen realisieren) zu positionieren. Cash und einen guten Namen (selbst BP!) sind reichlich vorhanden. Btw – und sollten Shell/BP sich zusammen tun, wird es umso spannender. Beide …


Ihre Karriere bei Shell | Shell Germany
Sind Sie bereit? Wollen Sie neue Karrierechancen erkunden und Ihre Karriere voranbringen? Entdecken Sie, welche Karrieremöglichkeiten Shell Ihnen bietet.


OPEC + | Aktienforum | Aktien Forum | Diskussionsboard …
Cash und einen guten Namen (selbst BP!) sind reichlich vorhanden. Btw – und sollten Shell/BP sich zusammen tun, wird es umso spannender. Beide haben ihre Felder geschaffen, um sich zeitnah zu etablieren im Markt der Zukunft – weg vom Öl. Klimaneutral und zum “Tesla” der Zukunft zu werden.


Shell Update — Ein unterbewertetes Investment in Erdöl und …
Shell ist breit diversifiziert entlang der Öl-Wertschöpfungskette. Downstream. Im Downstream-Segment verdient Shell Geld mit verschiedenen Tätigkeiten aus der Verarbeitung und dem Verkauf von Erdölprodukten.Erdöl ist ein sehr nützlicher Stoff in unserem Leben. Es kann zu verschiedenen Treibstoffen wie Diesel, Benzin oder Kerosin veredelt werden.


Ölaktien – Finanzen100
Aktuelle Finanznachrichten und Informationen rund um das Thema Börse finden Sie auf Deutschlands innovativstem Finanzportal Finanzen100.


BP AKTIE | Aktienkurs | Kurs | (850517,BPAQF,GB0007980591)
BP AKTIE und aktueller Aktienkurs. Nachrichten zur Aktie BP plc (British Petrol) | 850517 | BPAQF | GB0007980591


Geldanlage: Mit nur drei Aktien gehört eine ganze Branche …
So teilen sich beispielsweise sechs Konzerne den Mineralölmarkt außerhalb staatlicher Förderer und Verarbeiter auf – BP, Royal Dutch Shell , Exxon Mobil , Chevron , ConocoPhillips und Total …


OPEC + | OnVista Börsenforum
Cash und einen guten Namen (selbst BP!) sind reichlich vorhanden. Btw – und sollten Shell/BP sich zusammen tun, wird es umso spannender. Beide haben ihre Felder geschaffen, um sich zeitnah zu etablieren im Markt der Zukunft – weg vom Öl. Klimaneutral und zum “Tesla” der Zukunft zu werden.


BERNSTEIN RESEARCH: Royal Dutch Shell A “buy” – boerse.de
20210104 – NEW YORK (dpa-AFX Analyser) – Das US-Analysehaus Bernstein Research hat das Kursziel für die A-Aktie des Ölkonzerns Royal Dutch Shell von 2100 auf 2300 Pence angehoben und die …
TPMS Tool

Tagged : /